| 26 May 2013, 20.30 CET | |||
 SHKËNDIJA 1:1 TETEKS  (5:6 p.s.o.) |
|||
| HT 1:0 / FT 1:1 / AET 1:1 | |||
| Goals: 11′ Muzafer Ejupi – 69′ Darko Micevski | |||
Stadium: National Arena Philip II of Macedon in Skopje  |
|||
| Attendance: / | |||
| SHK | TET | ||
| 1. | Hadis Velii (GK)  24′ |
1. | Vanche Manchevski (GK) |
| 4. | Sedat Berisha |
2. | Aleksandar Krsteski  49′ |
| 6. | Ardian Cuculi |
4. | Egzon Bejtulai 86′ |
| 7. | Eljmedin Redjepi  113′ |
5. | Igor Kralevski 86′ |
| 8. | Artim Polozhani 78′ |
6. | Miroslav Jovanoski 90′ |
| 10. |  Gjelbrim Taipi |
7. | Bobi Bozhinovski (C) |
| 16. | Mevlan Murati |
8. | Darko Micevski 113′ |
| 18. | Nenad Mishkovski |
9. |  Genc Hyseni |
| 19. | Muzafer Ejupi |
13. | Filip Despotovski |
| 20. | Ardit Shakjiri 27′ |
14. | Dragan Nachevski 65′ |
| 22. | Muhamed Useini (C) AFT |
22. | Martin Blazhevski |
| Substitutes: | |||
| 5. | Medjit Neziri |
3. | Vlatko Drobarov  113′ |
| 11. |  Lovre Čirjak |
10. | Aleksandar Uroshevikj |
| 12. | Besir Nuhi (GK) 27′ |
12. | Dejan Siljanovski (GK) |
| 15. | Ilir Djemaili |
18. | Kristijan Toshevski |
| 24. | Burhan Aliji 78′ |
30. | Ivan Nastevski 90′ |
| 25. | Nuriman Ismaili |
31. | Filip Petkovski 65′ |
| 28. | Jasir Selmani 113′ |
91. | Nikola Petkovski |
| Coaches: | |||
| Artim Shakjiri |
Gorazd Mihailov |
||
| Officials: | |||
| Referee: Aleksandar Stavrev (Skopje ) |
|||
| Assistants: Marjan Kirovski & Dushko Milosheski (Skopje ) |
|||
| Fourth official: Nikola Karakolev (Shtip ) |
|||
| Additional referees: Dimitar Mechkarovski & Dejan Jakimovski (Skopje ) |
|||
NOTE: The match was originally scheduled for May 22, but was interrupted after just 12 minutes after both ultras groups were chanting nationalistic chants. The replay was played behind closed doors.
The penalty shoot-out:
| Shkëndija | 5 | 6 | Teteks |
| Muzafer Ejupi | X | O | Ivan Nastevski |
| Burhan Aliji | O | X | Filip Despotovski |
| Jasir Selmani | O | O | Vlatko Drobarov |
| Ardian Cuculi | O | O | Filip Petkovski |
| Gjelbrim Taipi | O | O | Igor Kralevski |
| Muhamed Useini | O | O | Vanche Manchevski |
| Sedat Berisha | X | O | Genc Hyseni |
Highlights (Macedonian commentary):